Are Handmade Tiles Worth It? The Beauty and Challenges of Handmade Tiles
Handmade tiles have become one of the most coveted design details in high-end remodels. Their slight imperfections, rich textures, and artisanal feel bring warmth and authenticity to kitchens, bathrooms, and entryways. But while their beauty is undeniable, homeowners often wonder: are handmade tiles really worth it?
Why San Diego Homeowners Love Them
In coastal areas like Encinitas, Solana Beach, Del Mar, Carlsbad, and La Jolla, homeowners often lean toward warm minimalism, natural materials, and soft textures. Handmade tiles pair beautifully with that design style. Their irregular edges and gentle glaze movement complement plaster walls, wood cabinetry, and stone surfaces commonly used in modern San Diego remodels.
Where Handmade Tiles Stand Out
Handmade tile shines in areas where people can appreciate the craftsmanship up close, such as:
Kitchen backsplashes
Shower walls
Fireplace surrounds
Mudroom or entry flooring
Bar niches
They add character and dimension to simple layouts without overwhelming the space.
The Challenges to Consider
Of course, artistry comes with a few trade-offs. Handmade tiles can cost two to three times more than factory-made alternatives, and because each piece varies slightly, installation is more time-consuming. Your tile installer will need to carefully plan spacing and alignment to preserve that organic look without compromising functionality.
Lead times can also be longer, especially if you’re sourcing from small studios or overseas artisans. And while those variations are part of their charm, they’re not ideal for everyone. Some homeowners prefer the precision and uniformity of machine-made tiles.
Balancing Aesthetics and Practicality
If you love the handmade look but not the full cost, consider mixing materials. Many homeowners choose handmade tiles for accent areas, like a backsplash or shower niche, and pair them with standard field tiles elsewhere. This approach balances visual impact with budget and simplifies installation.
Ultimately, whether handmade tiles are “worth it” depends on your priorities. If you value uniqueness, tactile beauty, and timeless design, they’re hard to beat. But if you’re looking for a faster, more predictable installation, a high-quality manufactured tile may be the better fit.
FAQ
Are handmade tiles worth it?
Yes—if you value texture, variation, and a timeless, custom look. They offer a level of character that machine-made tiles can't replicate.
Are handmade tiles more expensive?
Typically, they cost two to three times more than mass-produced options. Pricing depends on the maker, glaze, shape, and lead time.
Do handmade tiles require special installation?
Yes. Because each tile varies slightly, installers need more time to adjust spacing and layout. This can increase labor costs.
Can handmade tiles be used in showers?
Absolutely. Handmade tiles work beautifully in showers as long as they’re properly sealed (if porous) and installed by an experienced tile setter.
How do handmade tiles hold up in coastal homes?
Very well. Their natural variations pair seamlessly with coastal materials, and most are durable enough for kitchens, bathrooms, and fireplaces.
Where should I use handmade tile in my home?
They’re perfect for backsplashes, shower walls, fireplace surrounds, and accent areas where detail can be appreciated.
What’s the difference between handmade and machine-made tile?
Machine-made tiles are uniform, consistent, and easier to install. Handmade tiles are unique, textured, and artisan-crafted, with natural variation.
How long do handmade tile orders take?
Lead times range from 4–12 weeks depending on the studio, glaze selection, and order size.
Thinking About Remodeling?
A well-chosen material palette can completely transform a space. Whether you’re refreshing a bathroom or planning a full kitchen remodel, thoughtful design decisions, like where to incorporate handmade tiles, can make all the difference. Curious how handmade tiles could work in your remodel? Reach out and let’s talk through the options.